Monday, April 25, 2011

[rti4empowerment] Re: Lights And Safety

 

Hello all,


This latest report shows the utter apathy and lack of interest to do anything which can lead to better safety and security of pedestrians, motorists, and other users of roads and foot paths in Mumbai


That it is not a new situation, and that only a few are not working is a falsity, it has been so since 2004, and even the World Bank, which has, for reasons best known to them, helped finance this, and other such fund draing projects of MMRDA, MSRDC, MCGM, etc


As a matter of fact, the JVLR, long stretches of Eastern Express Highway, AYJ Western Express highway, LBS marg, SV Road, Mahim Causeway, and numerous service roads and by lanes are

01 Not lit

02 Poorly lit

03 After road widening, either the lamp posts are not reinstated, or even if they are, the lighting, if at all energised, is the same one meant for the say, two lane roads, and obviously half that required for the new double and triple width in terms of throw, spread, coverage, lumens

04 Deliberately not energised to save money on electricity bill, to make money on repairs, etc., to allow hoardings to be seen unrestricted, like just after South side of Bandra flyover the Mahim Causeway, not lit for the past God knows how many years

05 Deliberately not reinstated, to make money on new poles, bulbs, cabling, etc

06 Permit darkness for various reasons best known to the authorities

And many such.

Further, the dark roads are not only poorly lit, but are in such bad shape, that manoeuvering around pot holes, open manholes, damaged manholes, construction debris, median dividers left unattended, broken barriers, poorly lit vehicles, unseen turns due to uncleaned, unpainted cement concrete barriers and flower beds, etc.

The very least the authorities need to do is to paint all median dividers with white lime wash, with fluorescent additives, put working and effective reflectors all round all columns of flyovers, sky walks, foot over bridges, metro barricades and open construction areas, etc., not just some decorative light garlands which go out of order in no time, and thereafter never repaired,  or replaced, etc.

Bus stops of BEST are also totally neglected.

Mostly they act as advertisement hoardings, passengers are just secondary, the inside of the bus stops are so dark, specially in remote places of Mumbai,  its scary for even the able bodied.

Basically, its a bad joke on the Citizens of Mumbai, such civic infrastructure is totally neglected and the cheapest, most untenable excuses are given to justify this deficiency of service.

Thanqx.

Jagdeep DESAI
Architect

Secretary
Founder Trustee
Forum for Improving Quality of Life in Mumbai Suburbs


>>>

Drive through the darkness on JVLR

By: Ranjeet Jadhav  

Absence of streetlights in stretches on the crucial road has made commuting extremely dangerous for night-time motorists

Driving on the Jogeshwari-Vikhroli Link Road (JVLR) has become nightmarish for commuters, due to the unavailability of streetlights in spots on the stretch, including the L&T Junction and the Gandhi Nagar Junction bridge over the JVLR railway line. Senior Police Inspector (Traffic) R C Patil from Saki Naka said, "There is work pending on the L&T Junction flyover. Thus the streetlights are not working. We have asked MMRDA to install radium reflectors, so commuters can easily distinguish between the two lanes."


No lights: Motorists drive on the Jogeshwari-Vikhroli Link Road in spite 
of poor visibility as the streetlights are not working. Pic/Mahesh Chafe


Asked about accidents due to darkness in the area, the official assured that no incidents had been reported. 
"Motorists driving on this stretch speed up their vehicles at night. We will place barricades in a zig-zag manner, so motorists are compelled to slow down," he said. A visit made by MiD DAY on Saturday night revealed that none of the streetlights were working. Motorists were speeding up vehicles in the deserted stretch, in spite of poor visibility. MMRDA officials claimed that MSRDC was responsible for the stretch. None of the MSRDC officials, however, were available for comment.

Motorists speak
Jogeshwari resident Kapil Tiwari said "I drive on this stretch daily. Driving is a horrifying experience on the L&T Junction. There are no lights. At any moment another motorist can hit me from behind."



>>>

World Bank stumbles on pitch-dark JVLR
Published: Saturday, Feb 7, 2009, 2:19 IST 
By Ninad Siddhaye | Place: Mumbai | Agency: DNA

World Bank (WB) officials have conveyed their concern over the problems faced by motorists due to lack of adequate street lighting on the Jogeshwari-Vikhroli Link Road (JVLR) to Mumbai Metropolitan Regional Development Authority.

The bank representatives concluded their fortnightly review mission on Friday with a wrap-up meeting with senior state government officials. DNA had carried a report about the pathetic state of lights on the 10.4 km-long JVLR.

Many stretches of the road, which is a part of the WB-funded Mumbai Urban Transport Project (MUTP), are still without lamp posts.

When asked about the difficult situation faced by many motorists, Hubert Nove Josserand, team leader of the mission, did admit that there were issues still pending.

"We have observed the road and there is lack of proper street lighting. Although the speed of implementation of road work is satisfactory, lighting still remains a big issue. We have conveyed our concern regarding this to MMRDA," said Josseran.

Work for the road began way back in December 2004 in three phases. Though the first and third phases are complete, the second still remains to be done.

When asked about safety of motorists, Josserand said that it was the duty of the authorities concerned to complete the lighting on the road quickly. "The bank is just the facilitator. There are certain complications near IIT which are being sorted out. Even the issue of lighting should be taken care of," said Josserand.

The other road in MUTP under scanner is the Santacruz-Chembur Link Road (SCLR). Construction of this 6.5 km-long road is also moving at a snail's pace. When asked whether poor planning was responsible for the delays in SCLR, Josserand said that it was an enormous challenge to construct a road with many impediments.

"Though the shifting of Mhada buildings coming in the alignment of the road is proving to be time-taking, I am sure this impediment will be removed soon," he said.

The World Bank mission has also expressed its satisfaction about the progress of the rail component. "We are getting four new rakes every month. It has made a significant progress and I hope it follows the time schedule," said Josserand.


>>>

On Sun, Dec 28, 2008 at 7:16 PM, Jagdeep DESAI <jagdeep.desai@gmail.com> wrote:
Hello,

In reference to this report


Though its probably totally futile in sending this communication, this is once again an earnest request to install the missing road lights, energise those which are installed but not lit, enhance road lighting where roads have been widened, and where the lamp poles have been shifted far away and far between.
 
Not to mention, the surreptitious but obvious removal of road divider medians, useless high visibility painting  of yellow and black oil paint on kerbs and medians, no appropriate lane markings, no 'stop' signs, arbitrarily painted 'zebra' lines which start nowhere and lead to nowhere, etc., on going road, flyover, infrastructure works are not barricaded, not lit, openings are broken in medians by locals for short cuts, one way and no parking signs are taken down and not reinstated, etc.
 
This is in general, all across the City.
 
I can say this with reasonable assurance, since I am fairly familiar with large parts of Mumbai's suburbs,  due to regular and frequent need to travel almost across Mumbai almost every evening / night.
 
If only officials would take a bit of trouble to go around in the night, and appreciate that there are any number of accident prone areas in the best of times, such as Sahara Star / AYJ WE junction, and when it is dark, raining, and some drunk drivers are on the loose, and the ubiquitous black autos without lights scoot all over the road, then it becomes terror.
 
Specifically, the North end of Mahim Causeway just before going under the flyover is without lights for the past few years, as is the portion just after exit onto Bandra side.
 
Light poles are there, maybe even the bulbs, but no light, after years and years!
 
Maybe something to do with the huge numbers of even larger hoardings which might be affected by such lights.

Many sections of Eastern Express Highway are in total black out since weeks, no 'work' on going there.

What about the AYJ Western Express Highway?

Image 701 shows a section just before Vakola signal, going South, this is the case since six months, what hapens in the night?
 
The road from Saki Naka to Powai, all the way to the Vikhroli flyover  is virtually without lights for as many years as the works going on, sudden unnotified diversions, turns, make it ideal for accidents, if it wasn't for God's Grace.

Nothing to do with undecided median dividers, as the good engineer from MSRDC states!

The lights are supposed to be on the sides, not in the centre.

And are we supposed to wait for years on end till the divider medians are decided?

Add to that the complete lack of visible median dividers, and small and large blocks in the road, uneven road levels between paver blocks, asphalt, concrete, make it one torture trail for all drivers, not to mention utter danger, and enormous waste of time for all, more so late nights, when people want to reach home as early as possible, but the disorder and chaos, and the driver indiscipline,  makes delays inevitable.
 
This is not something that I am imagining, but very clear and present for all to see and experience.

Have look at this image, 687, on MV Road, just prior the Leela signal, going West.

Is this dangerous or what?
 
The widened MV Road, ie Andheri Kurla Road is a classic case of haphazard work in all repects, vast exapnse of hard surface, done to the trained observer, in an unplanned manner, but which will be claimed to be as per some plan.
 
There is simply no sense in one way, contra flow till certain points, traffic lights in the middle of nowhere, then within ten metres or less, but without any logic, etc., drivers don't know where to stop, very convenient for MTP to compound drivers, I mean, whatever shouldn't happen, happens.
 
Its mind boggling, even more so, when the situation is completely man made, and which can be very easily set right by simple low cost, high value inputs.

The very least, the absolute very least, to white wash all median dividers, parapet walls, and road kerbs with lime wash to which is added fluorescent additives for glowing in the night.

This is a low cost, high value, fast, easy, cheap to apply,  option to the yellow and black oil paint which gets dirty very fast, attracts grease, dust, dirt, grime, peels off, and is far more costly.

The only road at present in Mumbai which is quite well done, is between Saki naka and Powai L and T.

The lane markings, zebra lines in place, enhanced by cats eyes, white and red which really give good visibility to the drivers, though the haphazard parking by LCV, MCV, HCV, is something to tackle.

Safety at night should be the first priority.
 
If only.
 
Which is that authority which will take the initiative to take stock, organise and implement?
 
We don't need committees, only a Few Good Men.
 
Thanqx.
 
Jagdeep DESAI
Architect
 
Secretary
Founder Trustee
Forum for Improving Quality of Life in Mumba / Suburbs
Forum for IQOLMS
 
+91 98 6922 7148
 
>>>

>>>

No kindly light to lead the way

There are no streetlights along various stretches of Jogeshwari-Vikhroli Link Rd

Ninad Siddhaye

If you have to drive along the Jogeshwari-Vikhroli Link Road (JVLR) — one of the major components under the World Bank-funded Mumbai Urban Transport Project (MUTP) — please ensure that your headlights are in perfect condition, as there are no streetlights on many stretches of the 10.3-km road.
What is even more agonising is that agencies responsible for lighting the road are simply passing the buck. 
Work on JVLR began in December 2004. Motorists driving from Jogeshwari to Vikhroli still find it extremely difficult to drive on some of the patches, as the road is poorly maintained. 
The Mumbai Metropolitan Regional Development Authority (MMRDA), is the nodal agency for MUTP, has a standard reaction when asked about the problem. 
"Though MMRDA is the nodal agency, our job is limited to the rehabilitation and resettlement part of the project. The Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation (MSRDC) is constructing the road and hence the lighting system comes under their jurisdiction," said MMRDA spokesperson Dilip Kawathkar.
The MSRDC has a different excuse on the subject. "On many parts of the road, the median is yet to be decided. Unless that is finalised, we cannot start installing the lighting system," said MSRDC chief engineer, Subhash Nage. He added that it would take at least another month for the lighting work to begin. "We have already made the payment to the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM) for the street lights. They will undertake the work now," Nage told DNA. 
s_ninad@dnaindia.net

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
.

__,_._,___

No comments:

Post a Comment